Homeownership is the American dream, but it isn’t right for everyone. Before you take the plunge, Billshark walks through the investment, expenses, control, and mobility factors that should shape your decision to buy or rent.
Table of Contents
Is Buying a Good Investment?
The Expenses You Cannot Ignore
It’s All About Control
Mobility and the Five-to-Seven-Year Rule
FAQs
Home ownership: it’s the American dream. Scarlett O’Hara’s father drummed it into her head: “Land—it’s the only thing that matters; it’s the only thing that lasts.” So she was willing to do anything, anything!—to hang on to Tara.
When it comes to securing credit, homeowners are automatically seen as more trustworthy by lenders, simply because they have had to keep up the payments on their dwelling or risk losing it. Society generally feels that way, too. If you bring your intended home to Mama and Papa, they’ll be so much more impressed if he or she is a homeowner.
But does that mean it’s right for everyone? Not necessarily.
There are numerous points Billshark thinks you should consider before you take the plunge, and affordability is just one. Let’s look at other elements that should be part of your decision.
1 Is Buying a Good Investment?
Yes and no. Forbes magazine recently compared the return on investment (ROI) of homeownership vs. stocks. Since 1975 (the first year good data were available), housing has appreciated by an average of 4.5 percent a year. Stocks, on the other hand, average 9.8 percent annually, including dividends.
Interest paid on a mortgage, of course, is deductible, but it’s not dollar-for-dollar. If, say, you’re in the 28 percent income bracket, you can deduct 28 percent of the interest you’re paying for your mortgage loan, not the full amount. For example, if you paid $1,000 in interest to your lender in a calendar year, you could deduct $280 from your taxable income for that year. Hardly a windfall.
On the other hand, if you pay rent for 30 years, you’ll have nothing to show for it at the end of that time. If you pay a mortgage for 30 years, you’ll have a house that you own free and clear (but will still have to pay property taxes on).
2 The Expenses You Cannot Ignore
If you’re renting and the water heater dies, or the HVAC system goes out, or the roof needs to be replaced, all it takes is a quick phone call to the landlord to have it repaired. You’re not out a dime.
If—okay, when—those things go on the fritz in a home you own, you not only have to come up with the money to fix them (well into the thousands of dollars for each of these examples), unless you can fix them yourself you’ll have to hunt all around for a reliable repair person to do the work, and take time off work to supervise.
3 It’s All About Control
Or at least partly. If you own your own home, you can do anything you want with it (assuming you don’t have a homeowner’s association [HOA] to answer to). Rent it out, have as many people and/or pets living there as you want, paint it whatever colors suit your fancy, knock down walls, expand bedrooms, you name it.
A landlord won’t allow this kind of thing. Not only that, he or she can decide to sell the house at any time, as well as raise the rent at the end of every lease term. Of course, having a mortgage isn’t a guarantee your payments won’t increase, because the tax portion of it can go up every year, depending on how much your local jurisdiction raises taxes annually.
4 Mobility and the Five-to-Seven-Year Rule
Do you like to move around a lot? One thing you won’t have as a homeowner is mobility. If your job requires a move, or your significant other gets a job offer in another state, it’s much easer to get out of a lease than a mortgage.
The rule of thumb is, don’t buy unless you plan to stay five to seven years. That’s because, while it costs you nothing besides the down payment to get into a house, when you sell you’ll have to pay a realtor’s fee (typically 6 percent of the sale price), plus closing costs, plus moving costs. With the usual appreciation on home prices, 5 to 7 years is about average to recoup those costs.
And if we’re in a recession, which happens about twice a decade on average, you could be stuck paying your old mortgage plus rent or mortgage in your new location if you can’t sell.
In a future blog, we’ll look more closely at the financial considerations of buying vs. renting, but for now, think about all these other aspects when making your decision to buy or rent.
And be sure to let Billshark tackle your bills. If you do decide to buy, you’ll need money for a down payment, and we can help you on that road with the money we can save you today.
Share:
Billshark · Bill Negotiation Experts Helping consumers and small businesses stop overpaying on recurring bills.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is buying a home a better investment than stocks?
Not necessarily. Forbes compared the return on investment of homeownership versus stocks and found that since 1975, housing has appreciated by an average of 4.5 percent a year, while stocks average 9.8 percent annually, including dividends. Mortgage interest is deductible, but only at your tax bracket rate, not dollar-for-dollar, so the tax benefit is modest.
What expenses come with owning a home that renters avoid?
When you rent and the water heater dies, the HVAC fails, or the roof needs replacing, a quick call to the landlord gets it fixed at no cost to you. When those things break in a home you own, you have to pay to fix them—often thousands of dollars each—find a reliable repair person, and take time off work to supervise.
How does owning a home give you more control?
If you own your home and have no homeowner’s association to answer to, you can rent it out, have as many people or pets living there as you want, paint it any color, knock down walls, or expand bedrooms. A landlord won’t allow that, and can sell the house or raise the rent at the end of every lease term.
How long should you plan to stay before buying a home?
The rule of thumb is not to buy unless you plan to stay five to seven years. While it costs nothing beyond the down payment to get into a house, selling means paying a realtor’s fee—typically 6 percent of the sale price—plus closing and moving costs. With usual home-price appreciation, five to seven years is about average to recoup those costs.
Why does mobility matter in the rent-versus-buy decision?
One thing you won’t have as a homeowner is mobility. If your job requires a move or your partner gets an offer in another state, it’s much easier to get out of a lease than a mortgage. And in a recession—which happens about twice a decade—you could be stuck paying your old mortgage plus rent or a mortgage in your new location if you can’t sell.
Should You Own Your Own Home or Rent? page context
Should You Own Your Own Home or Rent? is a Billshark page. It can help you with your bills and your choices, and it can show you how to save.
Owning or renting a home? Compare investment returns, repair costs, control, and mobility before you buy or rent. Weigh the trade-offs and decide today.
Use this page to learn about Billshark. Then go to the part of the site that fits what you need. Small steps add up. You can save a lot over time.
We share this page to help you make sense of your monthly bills, your choices, and what to do next. Keep this page handy. Ask us if you get stuck.
This page links you to more help from Billshark. Use it when you want more detail or a clear next step. You can save a lot over time.
Got a question about a bill you pay each month? This page can help you find the best answer. Read on to learn more. Small steps add up.
Read each part of this page at your own pace. If you need more help, go on to a guide on your topic. It is free to read. Keep this page handy. Ask us if you get stuck.
We put facts and tips in one place. This makes it easy to learn about the bills you pay at home. We are here to help. It only takes a few minutes.
This page can help with real questions. You can learn about your plan, your account, and what you pay each month. Small steps add up. You can save a lot over time.
Use the menu and the links to go from a big question to the facts that fit your own needs. Keep this page handy. Ask us if you get stuck.
We keep things short and clear so you can choose well. You can then read more if you want to. It only takes a few minutes. You are in the right place.
The links on this page help you weigh your choices. They also help you see what you pay and what to do next. You can save a lot over time.
Our goal is to help you spot the bills you pay each month. We also share smart ways to keep them low. Ask us if you get stuck. Read on to learn more.
Come back to this page when you have a new question. It will still be here to help with bills and savings. You are in the right place. It is free to read.
We link the small choices you make each day to the big picture. That means your budget and what you spend at home. We make it easy for you.
Each part of this page helps you see what you need. It may be help with a plan, your account, or a good read. Read on to learn more. Small steps add up.
Use what you learn here to plan your questions. Look at your choices, then take the next step when you are ready. It is free to read. Keep this page handy.
Our pages link to each other. That way, you can find more help and still keep track of what you came for. We are here to help. It only takes a few minutes.
This page makes it easy to find the key facts first. Then you can pick a plan or make a change with less stress. Small steps add up. You can save a lot over time.
Good facts help you see why a bill went up. They also show you what to check before you call or reply. Keep this page handy. Ask us if you get stuck.
This page puts the key facts in one place. It can help you talk with a company about your bills and how to save. It only takes a few minutes. You are in the right place.
Our other pages explain the words you see on a bill. They also help you weigh the pros and cons of each plan. You can save a lot over time. We make it easy for you.
Our tips focus on real choices you can make. Start with the basics, then read a more detailed guide if you need one. Ask us if you get stuck. Read on to learn more.
This page is one of many that we share. Together they cover home costs, the firms you pay, and how to get help. You are in the right place. It is free to read.
Take your time and read this page first. It helps you see your choices and find out what to read next. We make it easy for you. We are here to help. It only takes a few minutes.
We set this page up so you can compare and keep reading. You will not need to hunt for what you want. Read on to learn more. Small steps add up. You can save a lot over time.
Monthly bills come with rules, terms, and fine print. This page helps you find the parts that count for you. It is free to read. Keep this page handy. Ask us if you get stuck.
Our pages give you a clear view of what you pay each month. You can then pick the plan or guide you want. We are here to help. It only takes a few minutes.
Some of our guides cover the basics. Others go into detail on one company or one type of bill. Small steps add up. You can save a lot over time. We make it easy for you.
It pays to read first and act later. This page links you to the next guide if you want to learn more. Keep this page handy. Ask us if you get stuck.
We share guides that help you make sense of your bills. They show your choices and the best next step. It only takes a few minutes. You are in the right place.
Want more detail on a bill, a plan, or your account? Check this page against the links we share here. You can save a lot over time. We make it easy for you.
We group our pages by topic to keep things simple. This helps you stay on track as you read about your costs. Ask us if you get stuck. Read on to learn more.
A bit of background goes a long way. It helps you spot what counts before you check a bill, change a plan, or call us. You are in the right place. It is free to read.
This page is part of our help library. It gives you clear facts and links so you can keep on reading. We make it easy for you. We are here to help.
Your needs can change, so come back any time. Our other pages can help you look into a new cost or plan. Read on to learn more. Small steps add up. You can save a lot over time.
We laid out this page to help you get the facts and compare them. You can then choose your next step with ease. It is free to read. Keep this page handy.
Homeownership is the American dream, but it isn’t right for everyone.
Home ownership: it’s the American dream.
When it comes to securing credit, homeowners are automatically seen as more trustworthy by lenders, simply because they have had to keep up the payments on their dwelling or risk losing it.
But does that mean it’s right for everyone?.
There are numerous points Billshark thinks you should consider before you take the plunge, and affordability is just one.
Yes and no.
Interest paid on a mortgage, of course, is deductible, but it’s not dollar-for-dollar.
On the other hand, if you pay rent for 30 years, you’ll have nothing to show for it at the end of that time.
If you’re renting and the water heater dies.
If—okay.
Or at least partly.
A landlord won’t allow this kind of thing.
Do you like to move around a lot?.
The rule of thumb is, don’t buy unless you plan to stay five to seven years.
And if we’re in a recession, which happens about twice a decade on average, you could be stuck paying your old mortgage plus rent or mortgage in your new location if you can’t sell.
In a future blog, we’ll look more closely at the financial considerations of buying vs.
And be sure to let Billshark tackle your bills.
Not necessarily.
When you rent and the water heater dies, the HVAC fails, or the roof needs replacing, a quick call to the landlord gets it fixed at no cost to you.
If you own your home and have no homeowner’s association to answer to.
The rule of thumb is not to buy unless you plan to stay five to seven years.
One thing you won’t have as a homeowner is mobility.
Billshark negotiates your bills for you — no savings, no fee.
Billshark helps lower internet, wireless, cable, satellite radio, and other monthly bills.
Our experts handle providers for customers and share updates throughout the process.
Customers pay only when Billshark finds savings on eligible bills.